The diet that set the stage for people in Okinawa living into their 100s, experiencing some of the healthiest longevity in recorded history, was one of either a poor agricultural society or one bearing the hardships of war.
As to the former point:
[Okinawans’] energy deficits are supported by historical reports of periodic crop failures that occurred in Okinawa in the early 20th century and a long history of marginal food supply.1
As to the latter point:
Near the end of World War II, in 1945, the US Army and Marine Corps invaded Okinawa with 185,000 troops. A third of the civilian population were killed; a quarter of the civilian population were killed during the 1945 Battle of Okinawa alone.
Before the 1960s, their diet was lower in calories and lower in the more expensive calories of meat, fish, dairy, and fat than the diet of today’s Okinawan population, but not by choice. In recent years the number of centenarians in Okinawa has declined (“the Okinawan mortality advantage has all but disappeared except in older cohorts (aged 65-plus)”1), as their diet has become more Westernized, more flush with meat, fat, and dairy food.2
Here is some data on the diets of Okinawans in 1949 (when those in their 90s today would have been in their 30s), with a comparison to mainland Japan where average and maximum lifespans were lower:
Okinawans ate a very low fat, high carbohydrate diet: 85% carbohydrate, 9% protein, 6% fat.
The foods they were eating? Mostly sweet potatoes (4 to 5 cups a day), brown rice (about a cup a day), vegetables, and legumes (mostly soy which was their principle protein source). About those sweet potatoes:
The Okinawan sweet potato, with a caloric density of 1.0 kcal/gram [rice is more caloric at 1.5 kcal/gram], has been the main carbohydrate of the Okinawan diet from the 1600s until approximately 1960, accounting for more than 50% of calories.1
The foods they weren’t eating? Not much fruit. Not many nuts or seeds. Not much oil – at 2% of calories, it works out to less than a teaspoon of oil a day. And hardly any animal foods. Fish, at 1% of total calories was about one 3-ounce serving a week. All other meat, including poultry, worked out to one small serving a month. One egg every two months.
The foods they ate had a low caloric density but a high nutrient density. That kept them lean but fit.
Micronutrients? They weren’t getting enough of several. Vitamins D, B2, B12, and zinc were consumed at just 2%, 45%, 27%, and 62% of Japan’s RDA.3 It didn’t stop them from living long lives, with good quality of life. Maybe we can retire the phrase, “Are you getting enough ____ ?”
They enjoyed low rates of coronary heart disease and several cancers:
Their diet began to change in the 1960s, so did their weight:
The BMI of adult Okinawans remained stable at a very lean level of approximately 21 kg/m2 until the 1960s. During the 1960s the Okinawan adult BMI began to rise. This was coincident with a shift to consistently positive energy balance.
Was the Okinawans’ traditional diet a primary factor in their longevity? I think so. One thing you can say for certain, it didn’t impede long life.
1Caloric Restriction, The Traditional Okinawan Diet, And Healthy Aging: The Diet Of The World’s Longest-Lived People And Its Potential Impact On Morbidity And Life Span, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 2007
2 Nutrition For The Japanese Elderly, Shibata et al., Nutrition and Health, 1992
3From Wilcox et al.: “Okinawa is located at a subtropical (26.4◦) latitude and subjects would likely have manufactured enough in vivo vitamin D from sunlight to meet RDAJ.”
Photos of Okinawans from National Geographic. The video stated that Okinawa now has the highest rate of obesity in all of Japan.
I’ve been reading that people believe the people of Okinawa eat, and ate, a lot of meat, especially fish and pork. This may be the case after the second world war, but it wasn’t the case prior to that, prior to the 1940s. And it was that early part of the 20th century when they ate the food that propelled them into very old age. When they added the meat, they began to die sooner.
Pingback: Vitamin B12, Average Intakes And RDAs | Fanatic Cook
Interesting that at times food was scarce. So they were forced to fast. Was it the fasting that contributed to the longevity?
Good point. I think it contributed.
no it’s the low meat intake that’s causing their longevity, meat and fish is inherently poisonous for humans in the long run
No doubt that the wars years may have impacted the diet of Okinawa but I doubt the food survey from 1949 accurately reflects their traditional food consumption. Does anyone honestly believe that an island population with an abundance of fresh seafood at their disposal would only consume it in small amounts. Also, they cooked using lard and they love their pork. I don’t buy these stories about their diet being near vegan and low-fat. At least, not their true traditional diet.
If their crops were failing, what were they feeding the pigs? The idea that a poor, war-torn population was free to fish and raise livestock is a romanticized view of life in turn-of-the-century Okinawa.
Pingback: What Is A Low-Fat Diet? | Fanatic Cook
Pingback: When No Diet Has Worked, Try This | Frederic Patenaude Raw Foods Diet
Pingback: Mediterranean Diet Post 2: Focusing On Greece | Fanatic Cook
Pingback: Indigenous Bolivian Tsimane Eat High-Carb, Low-Fat – Have “Lowest Levels Of Coronary Artery Disease Of Any Population Recorded” | Fanatic Cook
Pingback: Growing Up in an Era of White & Wheat Bread – Healthy life with Keto